Channelers are con artists

Just stumbled across a channeler called J.Z. Knight. She claims to channel the spirit of a 35000 year old warrior called Ramtha, who fought against Atlantis.

When she goes into her "trance", when she's actually being possessed by this spirit she starts speaking with an Elizabethan (the Queen's English, well the American stereotype of it) English accent.

Why would a 35000 year old spirit speak English? Secondly why would it have an Elizabethan accent?

Is she trying to suggest this guy from 35000 years ago spoke English? Doesn't she do even the slightest bit of research, even the same language 300 years ago would be virtually incomprehensible, what would 35000 years do to a language? Either way English wouldn't of been the language of Britain then anyway it would of been some ancestor to Celtic, or may be something even before that. English is a Germanic language mixed with a few other European bits and bobs from the settlers that came from the mainland in the last thousand years or so.

The very notion of a spirit of a 35000 year old person speaking Hollywood's version of the Queen's English is just barmy.

Her supporters would argue that the spirit uses her language to communicate. OK fair enough but why the accent? To me and anyone with more than 4 brain cells she's just putting on a jolly bad show.

She also claims this spirit was a warrior, well 35000 years ago? That’s way pre-warfare so how can you have a warrior?

Lastly I'll come to Atlantis. Atlantis didn't exist, it was a hypothetic society used by Plato to teach his students, the very frame work the course was in shows this, it was a conversation between two famous people that lived hundreds of years apart. Essentially Albert Einstein and Isaac Newton discussing a foreign hypothetical society. It also mentions this society was beyond the Pillars of Hercules (Strait of Gibraltar). The ancient Greek equivalent of a long time ago in a galaxy far far away.

I mean come on, if you’re gonna bullshit everyone and screw people out of money at least make the story remotely believable, something that can’t be debunked so easily.

People like this should be thrown in jail for fraud, and people who claim to talk to people's recently deceased relatives should be thrown in jail for fraud and being bastards who are seriously screwing with people's emotions.

Trackback address for this post

Trackback URL (right click and copy shortcut/link location)

6 comments

Comment from: Ibbeep [Visitor]
He Paul have you ever checked this out?
Its James Randi Educational Foundation. They will give ANYONE a million dollars if they can prove any type of paranormal activity. Weather it be telepathic or ghosts. Check it out youll get a kick out of it.

www.randi.org
6th July 2006 @ 17:32
Comment from: Paul Smith [Member] · http://www.dasmirnov.net/
I'm well aware of James Randi and the contributions he's made to the skeptic movement. :)
6th July 2006 @ 22:26
Comment from: Darth Urra\' [Visitor]
I was wondering; are you a teacher of somekind? You know alot about almost every subject, and have very intelligent answers, including this one^.

(P.S.- Atlantis might not be real, but I'm sure that there was at on etime a civilization that was flooded and now their buildings are under an Ocean's surface.)
11th July 2006 @ 00:23
Comment from: Paul Smith [Member] · http://www.dasmirnov.net/
There are some sunken buildings along the Mediterranean coast, but these aren't Atlantis, which is in the Atlantic, hence the name.
11th July 2006 @ 16:38
Comment from: Dan Buddle [Visitor]
Hi sorry this isn't a comment but i wanted to e-mail you and your e-mail adress was not on your blog (i think),
I was e-mailing your buddy the dialy creationism guy looking for some answers. Um he won't talk to me now i think. Can you e-mail me to say so i can reply with the same questions.
thanks Dan x
11th July 2006 @ 18:52
Comment from: Anthony [Visitor]
I have read the 2004 book, A Beginner's Guide To Creating Reality, and it is to my mind convincingly written. That's in writing. When I saw a clip on the Ramtha.com website of a channeling, it did not seem like the same source, but then the website would have believe that it is.

Personally, I am searching for the truth, to find some faith, and understand my place on this this planet. However, every New Age book I read is soon lost among the squabbling, disagreements about it and sceptics, like yourself.

Still if nothing else the book was a great read.
24th July 2006 @ 12:05

Leave a comment


Your email address will not be revealed on this site.

Your URL will be displayed.
PoorExcellent
(Line breaks become <br />)
(Name, email & website)